Well, this was a bit more complicated than I thought it would be. It turns out Toothless has a lot of different looks in the film! So I’ve matched all that I could and also included a neon green glow-in-the-dark eye that seems to fit in with a lot of the fanfic images of
Toothless.
Glow yellow
Glow pale green
Glow pale green (cat pupil)
Fan-fic style and other colors in round and cat eyes not shown above: 
Neon glow green
Are there any movie characters you would like me to match up? Comment below and let me know!
suncatchereyes.wordpress.com 
Awesome! Are the glow in the dark cat pupil eyes new? I recently got some GID eyes, but don’t think they are cat pupils. Those will be great for dragons!
They’re not all new, but I did mix up a couple of the green shades for Toothless 🙂 Thanks!